Blog
Disgruntled. And The Definition Of Art, Visually Speaking. (a postscript added 3 12 2016)
Greetings,
Welcome to the Cooper studio, Lipetsk.
I was disgruntled yesterday morning. And though that word always makes me think of barnyard critters, I'm sure it's the word I need to be using today. May I explain?
I just reread some old material, and came across this quote:
"When I judge art, I take my painting and put it next to a God made object like a tree or flower. If it clashes, it is not art."
Supposedly Cezanne said that. I know, really? How do the record keepers/quotes keepers authenticate this stuff? But anyway, let's suppose they're right, and he really did say that. Would that make Paul C the first person to attempt to define art? To give us parameters for what art is? And ISN'T?
Okay, now let's get back to the objective of this post: disgruntled yesterday morning, reviewing material, the meaning of art. And explaining it all to you.
Every now and then, I read through some of the listings for art calls. I know this is not unique artist behavior on my part. But I will share that I have a system for this perusal.
1. Read the 'main-stream' listings (they pop up quickly with a google search 'calls for artists')
2. Note if they are re-occurring (annual events, biennial events, etc)
If yes:
a. what artists participated in the past?
b. what work was chosen?
c. is my work polar opposite, or should I consider the event?
If not a re-occurring event:
a. who is the juror for this event?
b. what gallery or organization is sponsoring the event?
c. what kind of work is the gallery usually interested in?
- again, is my work polar opposite?
- or might this be a fit?
I got into trouble when I hit the the item: If yes: b. what work was chosen?
That is the point where I encountered disgruntled.
Now, I've already given you the Cezanne quote about what is art, and what isn't. When you look in anybody's dictionary, under the word ART, does it say Cezanne first defined art? I think not. And how many people have tried the task since then? And have you really given any of them any credit or regard??
What I tell you in these next few words will impress you even less regarding the definition of art, even LESS than what a truly famous painter once said (supposedly :) )
But back to that word, disgruntled: I viewed many examples of If yes: b. what work was chosen?
I viewed rope casually draped over a hook, and I viewed six shoes glued to a floor. I viewed a canvas with three lines painted on it. I viewed strips of plastic stuck on a wall. I was not inclined to ask a question. I did not feel like taking part, getting involved. It was not beautiful. I felt no emotional attachment.
Then I read the accompanying artist statement/juror comment. The ones with the flowery language. The ones that help us understand why plastic bags stuck on a wall are destined to be famous. Or not.
I know, I know. Who am I to say what IS art, and what ISN'T? I already told you my words of definition won't take your breath away. But that stuff I looked at? All those images on my screen? All those If yes: b. what work was chosen? All those images of things?
They make me want to ask:
If an image has to have gibberish-verbage accompanying it, to make it accepted, then why?
We artists and art lovers are participating in the venue of visual art. Shouldn't we be able to look, see and FEEL without someone telling us what to feel?
This morning, I shelved yesterday's disgruntled. I am moving onward. I am thinking of writing a new artist statement. One full of mumbojumbo art-professional-speak. It will wax eloquent of the new direction of my work. It will carry on about how my new work refutes the current-current of art jurors. This new statement will emphasize my theory that it's only art IF it says something - no words required.
I know, I know. I am not the first artist to say this, but I am the next :)
And now before someone asks the question about what's the meaning of life :) .... I'll just say, thanks for stopping by.
Later, Karen
The postscript: one month past the writing of this blog post, I find this gem from Sara at Painters Keys:
"I recently visited an art dealer who took pains to tell me about an artist’s process of layering house paint on a strip of linoleum to achieve a linoleum-y-looking house-painty thing."
Yes, that sums it all up pretty well....
Leave a Comment