Blog

1/15/2016 12:46:32 AM

Disgruntled. And The Definition Of Art, Visually Speaking. (a postscript added 3 12 2016)

KCooper / 11 Comments
Topics: about painting | about seeing 

Greetings,

Welcome to the Cooper studio, Lipetsk.

I was disgruntled yesterday morning.  And though that word always makes me think of barnyard critters, I'm sure it's the word I need to be using today.  May I explain?

I just reread some old material, and came across this quote:

 

"When I judge art, I take my painting and put it next to a God made object like a tree or flower.  If it clashes, it is not art."

 

Supposedly Cezanne said that.  I know, really?  How do the record keepers/quotes keepers authenticate this stuff?  But anyway, let's suppose they're right, and he really did say that.  Would that make Paul C the first person to attempt to define art?  To give us parameters for what art is?  And ISN'T?

Okay, now let's get back to the objective of this post:  disgruntled yesterday morning, reviewing material, the meaning of art.  And explaining it all to you. 

Every now and then, I read through some of the listings for art calls.  I know this is not unique artist behavior on my part.  But I will share that I have a system for this perusal.

 

1.  Read the 'main-stream' listings  (they pop up quickly with a google search 'calls for artists')

2.  Note if they are re-occurring (annual events, biennial events, etc)  

If yes:

   a.  what artists participated in the past?

   b.  what work was chosen?

   c.  is my work polar opposite, or should I consider the event?

If not a re-occurring event:

   a.  who is the juror for this event?

   b.  what gallery or organization is sponsoring the event?

   c.  what kind of work is the gallery usually interested in?

    -   again, is my work polar opposite?

    -   or might this be a  fit?

 

I got into trouble when I hit the the item:  If yes: b. what work was chosen?

That is the point where I encountered disgruntled.

Now, I've already given you the Cezanne quote about what is art, and what isn't.  When you look in anybody's dictionary, under the word ART, does it say Cezanne first defined art?  I think not.  And how many people have tried the task since then?  And have you really given any of them any credit or regard??

What I tell you in these next few words will impress you even less regarding the definition of art, even LESS than what a truly famous painter once said (supposedly :)  )

But back to that word, disgruntled:  I viewed many examples of If yes: b.  what work was chosen?

I viewed rope casually draped over a hook, and I viewed six shoes glued to a floor.  I viewed a canvas with three lines painted on it.  I viewed strips of plastic stuck on a wall.  I was not inclined to ask a question.  I did not feel like taking part, getting involved.  It was not beautiful.  I felt no emotional attachment.  

Then I read the accompanying artist statement/juror comment.  The ones with the flowery language.  The ones that help us understand why plastic bags stuck on a wall are destined to be famous.  Or not.

I know, I know.  Who am I to say what IS art, and what ISN'T?  I already told you my words of definition won't take your breath away.  But that stuff I looked at?  All those images on my screen?  All those If yes: b.  what work was chosen?  All those images of things?  

They make me want to ask:  

If an image has to have gibberish-verbage accompanying it, to make it accepted, then why?

We artists and art lovers are participating in the venue of visual art.  Shouldn't we be able to look, see and FEEL without someone telling us what to feel?

This morning, I shelved yesterday's disgruntled.  I am moving onward.  I am  thinking of writing a new artist statement.  One full of mumbojumbo art-professional-speak.  It will wax eloquent of the new direction of my work.  It will carry on about how my new work refutes the current-current of art jurors.  This new statement will emphasize my theory that it's only art IF it says something - no words required.

I know, I know.  I am not the first artist to say this, but I am the next :)

And now before someone asks the question about what's the meaning of life :) ....   I'll just say, thanks for stopping by.

Later, Karen

 

The postscript:  one month past the writing of this blog post, I find this gem from Sara at Painters Keys:

 

"I recently visited an art dealer who took pains to tell me about an artist’s process of layering house paint on a strip of linoleum to achieve a linoleum-y-looking house-painty thing."

 

Yes, that sums it all up pretty well....

Share This Post


Comments

11 Responses to Disgruntled. And The Definition Of Art, Visually Speaking. (a postscript added 3 12 2016)

Wow! I have to say I deal with the same issues in art. I am a photographer (more representational than not). Often, I think jurors are seeking to be shocked rather than astonished by beauty.

This rings true.
I'd like to share something that relates to this, and may be a part explanation. Several years ago when I was working for my MFA, one of the professors, an Art Historian, took my graduate painting class to review a show at the University gallery. I found it interesting that he instantly gravitated to paintings that visually incorporated written material in the actual work. At the time, I surmised it was because Art Historians are "word smiths" in their relationship to Art. Therefore, it was natural he would be attracted to the depicted word.
Now, with a few "years under my belt", I make a wider speculation about the incident and what it reveals about the current state of Art. In today's world, It's Art Critics who control which artists are or aren't worthy, who are the upcoming "stars", who should museums collect etc.; and, forgive me for being a little overdramatic, but who "lives or dies" as an artist!
I may be wrong; but I bet most, but not all critics, have an A.H. background. So, to them, "words" and written explanations may have become more important than direct visual communication. I apologize to any Critics who don't fit into my speculation.
Words need a brain to translate meaning, so it's not exactly a "direct" experience. On the other hand, Art can communicate directly to the "soul" with it's visual message (as well as the brain).
Which is more effective? Well, I'm biased, but I feel the visual is where the real power of Art resides! And, I would be lying if I didn't admit to resenting the overwhelming control a few Art Critics wield in relationship to Art producers.
An interesting paperback, which I think all Artists and Critics should read, "The Painted Word" by Tom Wolfe was written in 1975. Amazing how pertinent it is is today!

Thank you for a very insightful article. Art is definitely in the eye of the beholder, to use a cliche - but I've always been intrigued and amused by the "gibberish" and artsy comments attached to "art". Years ago I was at the Modern Art Museum in San Francisco. There was an installation of 3 vertical panels about 2 x 6 ft., painted completely white. No texture, no variation in the white. Next to them was commentary of about 3 paragraphs of artsy B.S. That opened my eyes. Now when I visit a gallery or art museum I am determined to be inspired and not intimidated. I learned from my years of showing purebred dogs that opinions and competence will vary from judge to judge and a loss or "failure" needs to be taken with that in mind and not taken personally.

Boy, I've ranted about all of this myself. I graduated with an art degree as a"non-traditional student," (read: little old lady) and felt like I was surrounded by and living in the old tale, The Emperor's New Clothes. If a professor said something was 'art,' the students flocked to it no matter how far-fetched it was. One painting teacher asked me, "Do you want to make art, or do you want to paint pretty pictures?" The point of all of this is, it's not just the critics and galleries that are striving to be high-end. University professors are contributing to the B.S. in a large way.

Just because a magazine, critic or university says something is or isn't art, we can't be intimidated by their so-called expertise and allow ourselves, whatever sort of artist we are, to become marginalized. If we do, the next generation of artists will be the poorer for it. Allowing the self-proclaimed 'art police' to boss the rest of us around is a bad idea. Thanks for saying this right out loud and in such a public way.

I'm smiling again....

Love you Karen... I love the way you can be thinking or feeling the same thing I am, but that you can put it in such a light that it makes me smile. -- Thanks again!

I love you, too, Karen!!! :) You SAID IT...and my whole day is better for reading this. ~Six shoes glued to a floor. Hee!!!~ THANK. YOU. <3

Thank you for your comments! And nobody shouted 'blasphemy!' at me. (whew!) The folks who commented on the posting of this same article over at the FASO newsletter page, sounded of the same voice.
That makes me ask this question: is it because artists look at art SO MUCH MORE than the average person, that we are more dis(ahem)criminating (call it tunnel visioned if you wish) and the book-learned with the floriferous text just struggle to persuade us (call it con us, if you wish) with said text? :)
There was also a comment on that page referring to the people who glue shoes in the name of art (!!!) and that they DO remove all boundaries for the rest of who want to create something, maybe something with more substance. And there we have the golden lining in this whole matter, eh?
Thanks for stopping by!
KC

Hello Karen, Here's a workable definition: "Art is a word which summarizes the quality of communication".
Cheers, Bernie

Hi Karen-
Thank you for taking the time to write this. I teach beginners watercolor and the art they make is incredible ( they can't usually see it) and they need no words to explain their this and explain there that. I guess if you can glue shoes down and put it out as art go you- as for me I will take a pass :)
Peace,
Becky

I am loving this already! I will share a story: Some year ago now, a gentleman who worked with the Maine Art Commission came to middle Maine. The goal was to help mid Maine Artist among others...As David Greenham and his wife did some acting as well...Back onto my story: A gallery space was opened called the Pro Arts Gallery in Dover-Foxcroft Maine. The sculpture Wally Warren who lives in Maine had a sculpture in the exhibition. An obelisk with found objects on it. There were brightly painted found objects such as an old rake head, a flip flop, etc. I mention these as they were zeroed in on. I was manning the gallery this day. An elderly lady and her middle aged sone came in. Spied Wally's Found Image Sculpture. And the lady said, "And they call this art!" She had no knowledge of Wally a well known artist, The middle age son agreed.... They continued on throughout the exhibition returning several times without comment. Then, they stopped again! The son spoke this time. "This... he said (pointing to the flip flop) "This makes me think of when we were at camp.....(he preceded with his story of his childhood memory, and his mother an he chatted a few). Then, his mother pointed at the rake, saying that "My grandfather had a rake just like that one!" At this point I stepped up behind them and said. "It's working!" And stepped back a bit. You could see understanding in their faces at this point. As artist we are facilitators. We say what others cannot but do wish to say. Or we say what others feel needs to be said etc. We express according to our realities and these touch on others similar realities. It is an understanding of others that we use...as well as all the mediums we utilize to do so. It is about color, texture....etc. Now a bit of a switch: Humans tend to stack up the pros and cons of all we think and do. Compulsively we seek whole answers. We learn from the stacking. The answer is often partially known. We see in this the truest possible realities. The truest possible answer to what we think, and what we create. The story of what we create needs to ring true too because we all strive to understand it, and identify with it, what ever it is!

Pejj

How much is too much? That seems to be the question these days with what I am trying to do. I am new to the blogging so forgive me what I do not know, tell me and I will fall in line. I got the idea that one site and doing a blog is quite enough? LOL It seemed it took forever to put a blog together about the type of art I do. Then I learned I should focus it differently... Then I ran across comments about letting your self shine through via your work then tell about it? Any thoughts on this? I felt what I did needed defining so others would understand what it is about. The reason is it is found image art. It is different..... So I worked the FASO website....and have been given the idea I should do the fb web page about Shibui....and a lot of time is going into this. Any thoughts?

Best wishes! Pejj


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post